Viewing By Entry / Main
September 14, 2005
DV Screening an Asian Immigrant

Hey everyone.  So here's my cultural issue for posting.  They other day I was giving an annual physical to a middle-aged Japanese woman.  She had emmigrated from Japan to the US about 10 years ago, and married an American born man.  She spoke limited English, and came alone.  I was able to get through most of the physical without too much problem, but I noticed a big problem during the personal questions and domestic violence screening.  Not only was this woman reluctant to talk about her sexual life, but also did not give clear answers to domestic violence questions.  It got me thinking about this woman, and about all the cultural barriers facing her if she were being abused and wanted help.

I found this article here, which talks of some of the barriers faced by Asian and Pacific Islander communities.  Basically, women who emigrate here from these communities face man problems if they try and seek help.  The number one problem is of course language.  But that problem is deeper than one would expect.  Sure, the fact that many do not speak English, and that there are few interpreters is a barrier, but so is prejudice.  There are many people in this world prejudiced against those who do not speak their language.  And perhaps this woman's experience with that type of prejudice translated into her timidness and unwillingness to share about her life with me.

Customs too also play a role, with the rights a woman had back in her native country influencing the rights she may perceive she has here.  While all women in the USA have equal rights as men, not all women who emmigrate to this country have that same viewpoint.  Many countries are more or less patriarchal than here.  This could play a role with the patient I saw as well.

Money and family is also a factor.  This woman married an American, and moved to America for him.  Her family is all back in Japan, and her money is all tied up in her husband.  He is literally her support financially and emotionally here.  And both distance and pride serve as barriers to her reaching out to her family back home if there was a problem.

Basically, what I learned from this woman is that cultural differences between the patient and the caregiver affect the information a provider can gather, and subsequently, the care they can provide.  And we as future providers must keep our eyes open to these cultural differences, and be sensitive to them so that we may truely get to konw our patients so that we may help them.  Incidentally, I got the chance to see this woman again, and the second time she was more open with me, and I was able to find out she was indeed safe at home, and get some of the info I was unsure of before.  But had I just passed her off as being shy, and not thought of the cultural differences between us, I would never have gotten the answers I needed.

Comments

Race definately plays a role in the relationship betweeen patient and provider. I think that schools are really trying hard to make students more aware of things such as: domestic violence, sex and drug abuse. I have had many patients of different races feel uncomfortable talking about any of these issues. The main reason why they feel uncomfortable is because doctor visits are so short that they never ask these kind of things. If more doctors asked about these issues, patients would open up more and would be more willing to talk if there was a problem with any of these issues.


It was reassuring that she opened up on the next visit. I have not had to deal with a scenario like the one described, but found that the orientation standardized patient interview was a clear example of why you need to see the patient more than once to gain their trust. I was told that I was too forceful in trying to get details and answers. This was mostly due to the fact that the clock was ticking and I was being judged. I left feeling that I needed to have about 2 or 3 visits with this patient if I were to get the trust and answers I wanted. Adding language to the complex set of barriers is another challenge that may extend the period of time it can take to build trust.


It is true in my office. My doctor presses for time so much that sometime I wonder if there is a time for DV screening. According to what we are tought, we need to ask questions and this is all cool, but in real life, insurance companies and cost prevents doctors from doing so.


<a href = “http://www.reduce-infertility.com/”><b style=display: none>Male Infertility</b></a> MORE-SPERM is an all natural male infertility reduction formula that is proven to increase your sperm shack by 500%. A larger sperm shack means more intense orgasms and less male infertility.


<a href = “http://www.herbal-pills-for-weight-loss.com/”> <b style=display: none>Hoodia Gordonii</b></a> an effective and pure herbal method for gaining weight loss. 100% pure Hoodia gordonii diet pills has no side effects. It Work positively on your body and weight loss naturally.


<a href = “http://www.natural-herbal-meds-4-cure.com/”> <b style=display: none>Natural Herbal medicine </b></a> is the oldest form of healthcare known to mankind. Herbal medicine is the use of plant and herbs extracts for their therapeutic value. Most plants contain and produce chbical substances that aid in healing and other physical treatments.


<a href = “http://www.penis-enlargbent-pills-and-device.com/”><b style=display: none> Penis Enlargbent Pills and Penis Extender</b> </a> that works in helping you achieve your target of a bigger penis and better sexual performance, Penis Enlargbent Pills and Penis Extender has no side effects.


<a href = “http://www.herbalviagra.bz/”><b style=display: none> Sure Erect - Herbal Viagra</b> </a> is a natural cure for Male Impotence. Unlike Viagra or Cialis, Sure-Erect has no side effects, has a 99% success rate and its 100% natural Herbal Viagra. Herbal Viagra ensures guaranteed erection every time, more pleasure and greater stamina.


<a href = “http:// www.prevent-prbature-ejaculation-pills-for-free.com/”><b style=display: none> Male Prbature Ejaculation</b> </a> Prbature Ejaculation is one of the most common sexual problbs. Prbature Ejaculation condition is often described as being an inability to delay ejaculation to a point when it is mutually desirable for both partners.


<a href = “http:// www.free-cum-pills-for-more-sperm.com/”><b style=display: none> More Sperm Cum Pills</b> </a> MORE-SPERM IS AN ALL NATURAL MALE INFERTILITY REDUCTION FORMULA THAT IS PROVEN TO INCREASE YOUR SPERM SHACK BY 500%. A LARGER SPERM SHACK MEANS MORE INTENSE ORGASMS AND LESS MALE INFERTILITY.


<a href = “http:// www.human-pheromones-to-attract-opposite-sex.com/”><b style=display: none> Euphoria Human pheromones </b> </a> is sexual attractant for men and women, it helps to improve your sexual performance, satisfaction and enjoyment. human pheromones is a full proof and an oldest method of attracting opposite sex.